Despite fines, troubling behavior identified, MGC allows casino, Maddox to move forward for opening
The Massachusetts Gaming Commission (MGC), despite finding a troubling pattern in the Wynn Resorts leadership in the past and present, agreed to let the casino operators remain in control of their Everett project – clearing the way for a planned June opening with licenses, and CEO Matt Maddox, intact.
The decision came down on Tuesday evening
after more than two weeks of deliberation by the MGC Commissioners. Those
deliberations had followed an intense week of hearings April 2-4 at the South
Boston Convention Center, as well as a year-long investigation by the MGC. The
54-page decision laid out the stipulations of the decision, including a
record-setting $35 million punishment for the company and a $500,000 punishment
for CEO Matt Maddox – who remained suitable by a majority Commission vote that
was not unanimous.
The $35 million fine was far larger – nearly
double – the fine levied by the Nevada Gaming and Control Board in February
when they fined Wynn $20 million for similar breaches there. At the time, that
was a record-setting penalty.
The great silver lining for the Wynn
organization, however, was the first finding in the written report, which
determined that no one in the Wynn organization intentionally provided false or
misleading information to the MGC in 2013.
“…the Commission has determined that Wynn MA
LLC, Wynn Resorts Limited, Matthew Maddox, Elaine Wynn and Patricia Mulroy
remain suitable, subject to fines and conditions set forth in this decision,
and all new qualifiers are deemed suitable,” read the decision. “While the
Commission did not find substantial evidence that the company or any qualifier
willfully provided false or misleading information to the Commission (during
the licensing process) in 2013, the Commission did find numerous violations of
controlling statutes and regulations largely pertaining to a pervasive failure
to properly investigate…and to notify the Commission about certain allegations
“The Commission is deeply troubled by the
circumstances of these findings,” it continued.
“Specifically, the corporate culture of the
founder-led organization led to disparate treatment of the CEO in ways that
left the most vulnerable at grave risk. While the Company has made great
strides in altering that system, this Commission remains concerned by the past
failures and deficiencies,” continued the commissioners’ decision.
Despite being troubled, the MGC indicated
that it had decided it was in everyone’s best interest to move forward with the
execution of the Region A gaming license in Everett.
“Given our findings, it is now in the
interest of the Commonwealth that the gaming licensee move forward in
establishing and maintaining a successful gaming establishment in Massachusetts,”
read the report from the Commissioners. “One of the key metrics by which we
will measure that success will be the overall well-being, safety, and welfare
of the employees. A second but equally important metric is the importance of
compliance and communication with the regulator. This penalty is designed
to guarantee these practices.”
To help ensure future compliance and to
punish for past transgressions, the Commission imposes the following penalties
•The Commission will assess a $35 million
fine on Wynn Resorts.
•Wynn Resorts shall maintain the separation
of Chair and CEO for at least the term of the license (15 years).
•At Wynn’s expense, the Commission, as more
fully described in the decision, will select an independent monitor to conduct
a full review and evaluation of all policies and organizational changes adopted
by the Company as part of the Adjudicatory record.
•The Board of Directors shall provide the
Commission timely reports of all Directors’ attendance records of both Board and
assigned Committee meetings.
•Wynn MA, LLC shall train all new employees
on the Preventing Harassment and Discrimination Policy within three months of
•Any civil or criminal complaints or other
actions filed in any court or administrative tribunal against a qualifier shall
be reported to the Commission immediately upon notice of the action.
•The Commission will assess a $500,000 fine
on Wynn CEO Matthew Maddox.
•The Board of Directors shall engage an
executive coach and any additional necessary resources to provide the coaching
and training to Mr. Maddox focused on but not limited to (i) leadership
development, (ii) effective and appropriate communication for internal,
company-wide reporting and messaging, (iii) enhanced sensitivity to and awareness
of human resource issues arising in complex workplace environments that,
without limitation, relate to diversity (including disability), implicit bias,
hostile work environments, inherent coercion, sexual harassment and assault,
human trafficking and domestic violence and (iv) team building and meaningful
“Ensuring public confidence in the integrity
of the gaming industry and the strict oversight of the gaming establishments
through rigorous regulation is our principal objective,” said Chair Cathy
Judd-Stein in a statement. “Our licensees will be held to the highest standards
of compliance, including an obligation to maintain their integrity. The law of
Massachusetts affords the Commission significant breadth in our decision
making. With that comes an equally significant duty of fairness. We are
confident that we have struck the correct balance and met our legal and ethical
The $35 million fine will be accompanied by
a series of conditions, including an independent monitor to review and evaluate
the company’s adherence to new and existing policies.
Maddox was levied a personal fine, and his
suitability was confirmed by a majority vote that was not unanimous, the MGC
said. The fine, they said, came from his “clear failure to require an
investigation about a specific spa employee complaint brought to his
That complaint came from Hotel Operations
Director Brian Gullbrants – now an employee of Encore in Everett – and the
infamous “sensual massage” requested by Steve Wynn and his new wife in 2013 at
the company’s Las Vegas resort spa.
That said, the Commission did acknowledge
that Wynn Resorts had made voluminous changes to their corporate culture and
structure – something that was hammered home for hours upon hours by the Wynn
team during the MGC hearings.
The Commission concludes “[t]hese changes to
the company’s philosophy, training, and operations show a new found commitment
and focus on all levels of employees, which combined with the ongoing
successful business operations, continue to demonstrate that Wynn is likely to
be a successful operator in Everett,” read the decision.
Despite that determination, there was an
undercurrent of “troubled” findings repeatedly spelled out in the report.
Primarily, that related to information about settlements regarding Steve Wynn’s
conduct in the 2013 licensing process.
The report said most of the time, the
information withheld came at the advice of legal counsel, but that advice
should not have been followed.
“One of the troublesome undercurrents
driving this matter is that disclosure of information was often withheld
reportedly on the advice of legal counsel, both in-house and outside,” read the
report. “All persons involved should have known better.”
That troubling undercurrent also was
expressed in the lengthy analysis of Maddox’s qualifier status. While Maddox
was allowed to remain as head of the company, the decision was not unanimous –
meaning that some on the Commission believed he shouldn’t remain and voted
against him. However, they found that his shortcomings were due to incompetence
rather than suitability issues, and they required that he take training classes
on how to lead the company.
“Mr. Maddox presents a unique case given his
longevity with the company, exposure to information pertaining to the alleged
wrongdoings and settlements, and current role as CEO,” read the report.
“The Commission concluded that Mr. Maddox
has, at critical junctures, demonstrated questionable judgment and other
considerable shortcomings in many facets of his responsibilities as CFO,
President and CEO,” it continued. “The majority of the Commission determined,
however, that these shortcomings bear primarily on his competence, not his
suitability…These shortcomings are largely not matters of honesty, integrity,
good character or reputation…”
One of the most telling parts of the report
was the Preamble at the very beginning, where it was apparent the Commission deliberated
at length about the matter – and from the gut. In the end, though, it felt it
had rendered justice.
“We are confident
that we have struck the correct balance and met our legal and ethical burdens,”
The Massachusetts Gaming Commission (MGC) is
still deliberating amongst its members more than two weeks after closing
hearings into the Wynn Resorts/Encore Boston Harbor suitability determination.
The hearings attracted hundreds of eyes and
a great deal of media as well, but since that time, not much has happened
outside of closed doors.
A spokesman told the paper that
deliberations continue and a very public unveiling of the decision would take
place after that.
There is no
timeline right now as to when that decision would be made public. That decision
includes whether or not Encore keeps its casino license, who in the Wynn
organization will remain a qualifier, and what new members will be deemed
qualified by the MGC.
After viewing multiple surveillance videos
of patrons falling off stools, being overserved, urinating in public, getting
groped, and laid out on the sidewalk by the front door after closing time, the
Licensing Commission last week suspended the Chelsea Walk Pub’s liquor license
for 10 weeks.
The attorney for the Pub argued that the
Broadway bar has avoided violations in the past. But for Commission members,
the multiple incidents brought before it at its April 3 meeting were serious
enough to warrant the harsh judgment.
The Licensing Commission found the Chelsea
Walk Pub violated City ordinances by overserving patrons, selling liquor to an
intoxicated person, creating a noise or disorderly disturbance, and failing to
provide video surveillance. The majority of the violations resulted from
incidents responded to by the Police Department late last November.
In a letter to the Licensing Commission,
City Manager Thomas Ambrosino urged the commission not to take the reported
“A liquor license is a privilege and not a
right,” the City Manager stated.
The majority of the April 3 hearing revolved
around the showing of video surveillance footage from a number of the
Police highlighted one patron at the end of
the bar who had three drinks in front of him before stashing an unopened beer
in his jacket while the bartender wasn’t looking.
Meanwhile, police pointed out that at the
other end of the bar, a woman sat with two pitchers of beer in front of her
with no one else drinking from the mugs. In addition, the video showed the
woman encouraging another patron to put his hand down her shirt and grope her
Police Captain Keith Houghton said both
incidents violated the city alcohol serving ordinances.
Attorney Jeffrey Rosario Turco, representing
the Pub, put up a defense to the evidence, noting several times that the
patrons who were alleged to have been overserved seemed steady on their feet
and not intoxicated.
“With all due respect, that woman allowed a
man to go down her shirt with two pitchers of beer in front of her,” said City
Solicitor Cheryl Watson Fisher. “There are implications all over the place.”
Additional video and evidence showed a
patron leaving the bar and urinating outside on the sidewalk and a patron
weaving into the street before being spotted by a police officer.
Licensing Commission member Roseann
Bongiovanni was unmoved by Turco’s “not swaying” defense when it came to video
of one patron who left the bar then went back in after being allegedly
“He’s leaning up against the way, that’s why
he’s not swaying,” said Bongiovanni. “That’s some good evidence you have
Most damning was an incident that showed
several patrons and a bartender struggling for nearly 10 minutes to carry an
alleged intoxicated patron out the door after closing time. Once the man was
laid on the sidewalk, the bartender went back inside and locked the front door
of the bar.
“The bartender quickly closed the door and leaves
him out flat, leaving him pretty much to us,” said Houghton.
Turco did not dispute the evidence in that
incident, but said that the bartender in the video had been fired.
Chelsea Walk Pub owner Angela Palmieri said
the main problem has been that her staff has not stepped up.
“They don’t listen to what I tell them to
do,” she said.
While the Pub hasn’t come before the
Licensing Commission in recent memory for violation, Bongiovanni said it has
largely been because there weren’t City resources to police the establishment
before. She said the Chelsea Walk Pub has a long history of shenanigans.
“There have been so many instances at the
Chelsea Walk Pub,” she said. “These are just the ones you got caught for; it is
a disgrace to the city.”
In addition to the
10-week liquor license suspension, the Licensing Commission also voted to
reduce the bar’s operating hours from 8 a.m. to 1 a.m. to noon to 10 p.m.
On Wednesday, April 3, the Licensing
Commission approved a four-day license for New Hampshire-based Fiesta Shows to
hold a four-day carnival on the Chelsea Commons this spring.
During the short public hearing to approve
the license, Chelsea Police Captain Keith Houghton said the City’s public
safety agencies have never had an issue with Fiesta Shows. The company also
runs events nearby in Revere and Lynn, among other communities.
At-Large City Councillor Roy Avellaneda said
he’s had experience with Fiesta Shows owner John Flynn in the past, and that
Flynn has always run a tight and secure ship with his shows. In addition,
Avellaneda noted that Fiesta Shows will make a donation to the City’s summer
Licensing Commissioner Roseann Bongiovanni
said she did have some concerns about the carnival operating until 11 p.m.,
especially on Thursday night.
Flynn said while the license has the closing
time at 11 p.m., festivities and rides typically wind down around 10 p.m.,
giving police time to sweep the area by 11 p.m. Music and amplification is
usually shut down at 9 p.m., he added.
•In other business, the Commission denied a
permit that would have allowed for Friday night social events at the Rincon
Hondureno Function Hall at 194 Broadway. Commission members and City officials
expressed concern that the social night would effectively turn the function
hall into a nightclub.
•The Licensing Commission also approved a
liquor license transfer for La Esquina Mariachi Restaurant at 170 Washington
Ave., the former site of the Plaza Mexico restaurant.
The pastor and parishioners from the
neighboring church expressed concerns about the new restaurant, given their
experience in the past.
While the Commission approved the license,
members asked that the owners are mindful of the past history at 170 Washington
“You need to be very conscious of the
environment you are stepping into,” said Licensing Commission Chair Mark Rossi.
“Please don’t disappoint us.”
With plans to host four recreational
marijuana shops already at some phase of readiness in Chelsea, the Licensing
Commission is nearing a final vote on regulations for special additional rules
for those establishments.
On March 7, the Commission continued a
public hearing on the regulations, focusing on the topics of application fees,
locations of the pot shops, and security.
Commission Chair Mark Rossi said the
Commission should be ready to take a final vote on the regulations at its meeting
in early April.
The City is limited to four retail marijuana
Those shops will already be vetted heavily
before they reach the Licensing Commission for final approval. Other approvals
include a host agreement in place from the City and approved by the state’s
Cannabis Control Commission, as well as any necessary approvals from the City’s
Zoning and Planning Boards.
Rossi said the Licensing Commission will
grant the retail pot shop licenses in much the same manner as it does for
One of the questions raised by an early
draft of the Licensing Commission regulations was whether the Commission should
limit the shops to one or two per voting district.
The City ordinance already limits the
establishments to three zoning districts — Industrial, Shopping Center, and
Business Highway zones.
By the end of last week’s hearing, there was
general agreement among the commissioners that there would not be a restriction
on how close the pot shops can be to one other.
City Councillor-At-Large Roy Avellaneda
agreed that was the right move on the issue.
“I would oppose any sort of restriction on
the number of feet from one place to another,” he said. “We already have zoning
in place in the city and we don’t need to add another layer to that; we don’t
do it for other businesses.”
The Commission also agreed on a $500
application fee and $5,000 yearly renewal fee for the marijuana businesses.
While there were some questions about the
Commission’s role in looking at security at the establishments, City Solicitor
Cheryl Watson Fisher noted that there are already strong security requirements
from the state, and requirements are also written into the host agreements with
the prospective businesses.
Commissioner Roseann Bongiovanni said she
would still like to look at the host agreements to see how they address
security before taking the final vote next month.
“I don’t think security is going to be an
issue,” said Commissioner James Guido, adding it is more likely traffic that
could cause some issues.
According to the proposed regulation, the
Licensing Commission would not issue a license to anyone who has violated
Licensing Commission rules and regulations in the past five years. All licenses
are subject to zoning approval and state Cannabis Control Commission approval.
hours for retail shops will be limited to 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., and all signage
will have to be approved by the City, according to Fisher.
If one is looking to hit the local bars this
Cinco de Mayo, the options are going to be a little more limited than usual.
At its March 7 meeting, the Licensing
Commission disciplined two local restaurants for a variety of infractions that
will result in them losing their liquor licenses for the Cinco de Mayo weekend
on May 4 and 5. (The restaurant Cinco de Mayo in Chelsea was not disciplined or
called to the Commission).
In addition to losing its liquor license for
that weekend, the Commission voted to roll back Acapulco’s hours of operation
indefinitely, forcing the Fifth Street establishment to close at 11 p.m.
instead of 1 a.m.
The Acapulco punishment stems from an
incident last November when a security worker at the restaurant struck a
customer over the head with a police baton.
The Commission also enforced an hours rollback
from 1 a.m. to 11 p.m. – along with the weekend suspension – for Bar La Cueva
at 802 Broadway. That punishment was enforced for an incident where several
patrons were overserved, as well as for past concerns about noise and unruly
patrons at the bar.
In addition, Commission member James Guido
requested a hearing next month to consider revoking Bar La Cueva’s
The attorney for Acapulco said the issue at
his client’s establishment is systemic of a larger issue in the city, where
security at bars is handled by companies that act almost as paramilitary or law
Several commissioners agreed that there is a
larger issue that needs to be addressed in the city with bar and liquor
establishment security, but noted that Acapulco deserved a more forceful
discipline than simply firing its current security contractor.
“You say security is a problem, but you’ve
had the same company for a decade,” Commissioner Roseann Bongiovanni said.
The issues at Bar La Cueva seemed to extend
beyond the recent incident where two people were overserved, as several
commissioners noted that there have been noise and unruly patron complaints at
the bar for years.
In a letter, one neighbor stated that the
“karaoke singing by drunks is terribly loud and they overserve their patrons.”
John Dodge, the attorney representing the
bar, said for the incident in question, his clients acted responsibly and asked
the patrons who appeared to be intoxicated to leave.
But Bongiovanni noted that the bar has been
a problem in the past, including racking up a 14-day liquor license suspension
about two years ago.
“They have been a complete nuisance and
annoyance to the neighborhood; you can roll your eyes all you want, counselor,”
she said to Dodge.
Both the bars got off relatively easy
compared to Fine Mart, a liquor and convenience store at 260 Broadway. The
Commission suspended the store’s liquor license for a total of six weeks for
three offenses, including an incident where an employee struck a woman who was
intoxicated in the store, for selling nips after the enactment of the City’s
nip ban, and for the sale of alcohol to a minor.
City Manager Tom Ambrosino, an ardent
supporter of the City’s ban on 50 ml bottles of alcohol, said there needs to be
consequences for businesses that violate the ordinance.
“The ban has been
important in the city’s efforts to try to make Broadway a more attractive place
to shop and dine,” Ambrosino said. “We’ve spent a lot of money to make it a
better place. Having the nip ban in place is an important part of that. “(Fine
Mart) has a prominent place in the corridor and has to comply with its
Andrea Lopez and Elida Flores got a kick out of being cold on Saturday night, Feb. 9, at the Cronin Ice Rink. Scores of teens showed up for the first-ever Chelsea Youth Commission Skate Party at the Rink.
The Licensing Commission has continued a
hearing on special additional rules for marijuana establishments to its March
The commission opened the public hearing at
its meeting on Thursday, Jan. 17.
While the hearing did not generate much
controversy, commissioners did agree that they wanted more time to consider
several issues, including language limiting where retail marijuana shops can be
concentrated, and the amount the city will charge for application fees.
“I’d like to see more research and see what
nearby cities have done and what their challenges are,” said commission member
Currently, there are three applications in
the works for retail marijuana shops in the city. The city will allow a maximum
of four retail licenses.
According to the proposed regulation, the
Licensing Commission will not issue a license to anyone who has violated
Licensing Commission rules and regulations in the past five years. All licenses
are subject to zoning approval and state Cannabis Control Commission approval.
The operating hours for retail shops will be
limited to 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., and all signage will have to be approved by the
city, according to City Solicitor Cheryl Watson Fisher.
“We are trying to be a little more
restrictive now so we don’t have to clean up after the fact, like with liquor
licenses,” said Fisher.
The section of the proposed regulations that
garnered the most discussion among commission members was one which would limit
the concentration of where retail marijuana shops can be located.
Fisher noted that the language included in
the draft regulations, limiting retail shops to one per voting district and not
within 500 feet of another retail marijuana store, was not included by the
legal department. She said it was included because it was a request made during
a past public hearing on marijuana regulations.
“We already have a very small area in
Chelsea, and retail shops are already restricted to three zones and can’t be
within 500 feet of schools,” said Fisher. “It is already quite restrictive of
where you can put a facility.”
The city will allow marijuana establishments
in the Industrial, Shopping Center, and Business Highway zone.
Licensing Commission Chairman Mark Rossi
said he’d like the commission to have more discretion over where facilities can
“Our job is to factor in the input from the
community and the licensees,” said Rossi.
Much like it does with liquor licenses,
Rossi said the Licensing Commission will be getting input from the community,
police and fire departments, and other city officials when it comes to making a
final determination on issuing a marijuana license.
“This committee is uniquely situated to make
that determination,” he said.
Commission member James Guido said he would
like more information on limiting concentration in voting districts before
making a final decision on the proposed regulation.
Rossi also said he had questions about the
$5,000 application and annual renewal fee for marijuana establishments, stating
he would like to see a higher number.
Rossi said the application fees and
concentration of locations will be discussed when the hearing is continued at
its March 7 meeting.
“This is a big issue that affects everyone,”
•In other business, the Licensing Commission
adjusted its penalty for Rincon Latinos restaurant at 373 Washington Ave. In
December, the commission suspended the restaurant’s liquor license for eight
days spread over four weekends for repeated instances of exceeding its
Last week, the commission agreed to suspend
the license for two weekends in January, as well as for a five-day stretch
during the week when a new handicap bathroom will be installed by the
The new bathroom will allow Rincons Latinos
to increase its capacity from 17 to 28 people, according to John Dodge, the
attorney representing the owners.
Rincons Latinos Restaurant on Washington Avenue has been no stranger to appearing before the Licensing Commission over the past several months.
At the Thursday, Dec. 6 meeting, it was a case of enough was enough for the licensing commissioners, as they voted to suspend the 373 Washington Ave. restaurant’s liquor license for eight days. The suspension, largely leveled for repeated instances of exceeding the posted capacity of the establishment, will be served during four weekends over December and January.
A police inspection in October found 42 people in the restaurant, well above the posted occupancy limit of 17. Police officials also claimed there was missing signage and insufficient lighting in the restaurant.
Attorney John Dodge, representing Orlando Pineda of Rincons Latinos, argued that his client is planning to install a second handicap accessible bathroom in the restaurant. That move would double the occupancy limit of Rincons Latinos from 17 to 34, he said.
“That is the only thing that has been reducing the occupancy level in the restaurant,” said Dodge. “It isn’t a safety concern in regard to (the number of people) in the restaurant.”
“It’s just breaking the law and not following rules,” countered Mark Rossi, the Licensing Commission chairman.
Dodge said Pineda is doing his best to run a business and will spend upwards of $7,500 to install the new bathroom to comply with regulations.
“Mr. Pineda has put his life and soul into the place, and he lives right upstairs,” Dodge said.
Dodge also noted that the police withdrew a previous charge against the restaurant from the fall that people were illegally bringing cases of beer into and out of the restaurant.
“Mr. Pineda and his brother Ricardo are trying to do the right thing,” Dodge said. “They are doing their best to increase the occupancy. I question the fundamental fairness (of the charges).”
Commission member James Guido took exception to Dodge’s accusation of unfairness.
“They have had plenty of chances,” he said. “The biggest complaint now is the occupancy and we are going to try to deal with that.”
Commission member and Inspectional Services Director Mike McAteer said he has been dealing with the occupancy issue and plans for an additional bathroom since July with no movement on the issue from the Pinedas.
Rossi said Dodge was basically taking a “no harm, no foul” approach to the occupancy violations and that the Pinedas have not made enough effort to address them over the past six months.
“The explanation has been, ehhhhh, it’s a big enough place and nobody got hurt,” Rossi said. “They have not taken the proper steps to alleviate the matter. Now, you are saying give me more time so I can try to make this right.”
The commission members batted around several possible punishments, from a 30-day license suspension to outright revocation, before deciding on the eight-day suspension meted out over four weekends.
Rossi said if the establishment violates the 17-person occupancy limit before approval for expanding to 34 people, it will be subject to license revocation proceedings.
In other business, the commission took its annual vote to allow extended New Year’s Eve hours to 2 a.m.
The commission also approved giving a six-month extension to Samir, Inc. to find a new location to use a wine and malt beverage license.
It’s the case of the cases of Corona going in and out of Rincon Latino Restaurant.
Following a histrionic licensing commission hearing on Tuesday, Sept. 25 that saw the lawyer for the restaurant’s owners compare the proceedings to those in Russia and referred to the hearing to “a lynching,” the commission continued the hearing until its next meeting next month.
As the last hearing on a busy commission agenda, everything started calmly enough, as the commission heard a police report from officer Augustus Cassuci detailing two incidents he witnessed just outside the Washington Avenue Restaurant on June 22 and 23.
The officer stated that on Friday, June 22, he was passing by 373 Washington Avenue when he saw about 10 people crossing the street, with one carrying a case of Corona beer. The next day, Cassuci said he saw a customer carrying a case of Corona into the restaurant.
Where the hearing raised the ire of attorney John Dodge, who was representing the restaurant, was when Cassuci raised a number of issues at Rincon Latino Restaurant that were not included in the two-paragraph police report.
“On several occasions, there have appeared to be intoxicated patrons in front of the laundromat next door blocking the sidewalk,” said the officer. “Male parties have also been seen urinating on the sidewalk.”
Additionally, police Captain Keith Houghton said the restaurant often appears to surpass its occupancy limit of 17 customers and the curtains of the establishment have been closed, in violation of the law.
Police officials also showed the commission a photo taken from the restaurant’s security camera that they said showed the establishment as being over capacity.
“How am I supposed to represent (the restaurant) when all I have is a two-paragraph police report?” asked Dodge, who asked that the hearing be continued to the commission’s next meeting since evidence was introduced that he had not previously seen.
Dodge said the allegations leveled by the police had nothing to do with the original report of customers taking out or bringing in cases of beer.
“I don’t know what evidence is being presented,” he said. “We were not provided with any photos or any video, and Officer Cassuci is now testifying to public intoxication, urinating on the sidewalks, and closed curtains.”
Licensing Commission Chairman James Guido said a public hearing does not follow the same process as a court hearing and that the information being provided during the hearing was due process.
“Maybe due process in Russia, in America we are given the evidence before a hearing,” said Dodge.
Commission member Roseann Bongiovanni asked for calm, and suggested the commission continue the hearing for one month. The commission approved the continuance, as well as a request that the restaurant provide video of peak hours during the past several weekends to help determine if there has been overcrowding or other issues at the restaurant.