Chelsea Staff Want to Open Homebuyer Aid to Non-Residents After Only Three Approvals in 19 Inquiries

Lea este artículo en español

Chelsea’s down payment program for first-time homebuyers has approved three applications out of 19 inquiries, and city housing staff now want to loosen the rules, starting with the requirement that a buyer already live in Chelsea.

The recommendation went to the Affordable Housing Trust Fund Board for its meeting Wednesday, November 18, at 6 p.m. at City Hall. The agenda listed a staff recommendation to expand the program and a “potential vote to approve.” The meeting packet, posted on the city’s website Wednesday morning, includes a two-page memo dated November 16 from Lydia Malkemus, the city’s housing and community preservation manager. The result of the board’s discussion was not in the public record when this story was published.

Advertisements

What staff recommend

  • Income limit: raise it from 100 percent of area median income to 110 percent.
  • Residency: drop the rule that applicants must be current Chelsea residents. Current residents could still get priority.
  • Assets: raise the household asset limit from $75,000 to $100,000.
  • Buying together: study a pilot that would let two or more households combine their buying power to purchase a two-family or three-family home in Chelsea.

The program offers up to $20,000 toward a down payment and closing costs and is run for the city by Chelsea Restoration Corporation. The income and asset limits were not posted on the program’s public pages when we wrote about it last week; the memo puts them on the record.

Why: 19 inquiries, three approvals

According to the memo, the City Council appropriated $1.25 million to the trust fund board in 2020 to create the program. After a request for proposals, Chelsea Restoration Corporation was awarded $720,000, of which $600,000 is budgeted for direct assistance to buyers. At the $20,000 maximum, that is enough for 30 awards. A separate budget memo in the packet says $300,000 has been disbursed to Chelsea Restoration so far.

As of November 2, the memo says, Chelsea Restoration had received 19 inquiries or calls about the program. Three applications have been approved and two are under review. The nonprofit named three barriers: applicants were not Chelsea residents, were over the income limit, or exceeded the asset limit. Other inquiries went nowhere because the caller was not a first-time buyer, was not in the process of buying, did not follow up, or because the property did not pass the required home inspection.

On residency, the memo says some people were turned away “despite working in Chelsea, having children in Chelsea schools, or growing up in Chelsea.” Staff argue that buyers without those ties are still choosing to become long-term members of the community when they buy in the city.

On income, the memo says households between 100 and 110 percent of area median income earn too much to qualify “yet often still struggle to afford down payment costs.”

The co-buying idea

The fourth recommendation is modeled on a Boston pilot. Each household would have to meet the program’s income, asset and first-time buyer rules on its own, and each would have to live in the building as its primary residence. The property would have to be a two-family or three-family home in Chelsea with as many vacant units as there are households on the mortgage. The program today covers only single-family homes and condominiums.

Open questions

The board’s October 14 minutes, also in the packet, show the idea came up last month. Housing and Community Development Director Ben Cares told the board he had discussed the program with the city manager and saw a need to revisit eligibility, “particularly regarding the residency requirement.” Board member Alexis Turgeon asked whether a City Council vote would be needed to change the rules. Cares said he would find out. The packet does not give the answer.

The memo also does not give the dollar figures behind the percentages. Area median income limits vary by household size and are set each year by the federal government.

Also in the packet

  • Trust fund balance: $451,586.30 in unclassified funds as of November 16. The council is weighing a $400,000 transfer of preservation money to the trust; a committee takes that up November 24.
  • The Quinn Residences: a final closeout report from Broadway Capital CDPM says the 20 one-bedroom condominiums at 146 to 150 Williams Street were finished October 25, with a certificate of occupancy issued October 13. Three units are restricted to buyers at 60 percent of area median income, nine at 80 percent and eight at 100 percent. The project received $200,000 from the trust and $200,000 in preservation funds; the developer is asking for the last $10,000 from each.
  • Orange Street: $143,500 of the grant for the land trust homes at 41 to 43 Orange Street has been paid out, with $7,500 left.
  • Rental assistance: $47,500 of the grant to CAPIC has been paid out, with $52,500 left.
  • Attendance: the board was to consider a rule, borrowed from the Planning Board, that calls for a meeting with the chair or staff when a member misses three meetings in a row or four in a calendar year.

Buyers who want to apply under the current rules can call Chelsea Restoration Corporation at 617-889-2277. The trust fund board’s agendas, minutes and packets are posted on the city’s website under Boards and Commissions.